Wau! looks awsome
I want one of this, looks fantastic (sega saturn like), this controler is AWSOME, if i coud buy i will buy right in this second...my rating for this controler is "6"

Looks Good, But Plays Very Badly
This is possibly the best looking controller out there!! But that does not mean a thing, if it does not play well. The Xbox (s) Controller is way way better

Best Left Sealed...
I agree with most of the reviews here. As a fighting pad it's not very good, but as a collectible it is worthy. The thing I find worse about this pad si the location of the start and back buttons. They are placed over the 6 face buttons and are often hit on accident, which can ruin a game especially when you're playing online...

Not functional, but pretty.
I was very disappointed by this controller. When I first saw it I had high hopes for it. I was expecting near Saturn controller quality. Boy was I wrong. The controller does not even perform to the level of its PS2 counter parts. It feels cheep and the directional pad is a nightmare. I was not able to consistently pull of special moves. I was better off with the stock S-controller. But the packaging is nice and it does bring an Udon comic. If it were priced at $10-$15 I would probably purchase all 3 of them just to collect them, but never to use as a serious fighting pad.