One of the best games for PS2!!!
An awesome PS2 exclusive, with a nice storyline. The gameplay and graphics are the strongest aspects of this game. Took me about 50+ hours to beat the storyline, still there is plenty to be done in the game. A good choice for a Final Fantasy fan!!!

A fun rpg experience
This action rpg does a lot of things right. The graphics are tight for a ps2 game, and the production values overall are pretty high. There's plenty to do, and as others have said, the game will last you as long as you want it to.
What I find interesting is the flow of the game. The characters talk amongst themselves as you explore, and this helps by adding personality while there are long stretches of gameplay without any story segments

rogue galaxy... this was a tough one to rate...
it's really a 3.5 star game i think. i was really on the fence about this one. i think it holds its own against many of the PS2 RPGs (excluding FF, DQ and established heavy-weights).

[pros: awesome graphics/artwork, challenging battles, great battle system, fluid gameplay, weapon variety, useful map system, good interface]

[cons: laughable story, cliche villains, seriously lame script]

in regards to kain
my origional review, below yours is fairly accurate to the degree the game is a long as you want to make it, the game has a lot of sidequests, weapon fusions, monsters to hunt, completionists could easily speand over 60 hours + and still have a lot left to do, saying the game is boring is just your opinion, a lot of people liked this game, its well worth the money, and it has a fairly amusing yet epic storyline

better than FFXII??? no
Rogue Gaalaxy is good, but if you have to choose between RG and FFXII go to FFXII, rogue galaxy is too short and boring