Good Western, Average Shooter
COJ may take a bit of time to get used to, as it has a bit of a clunky feel to it at times, but it is certainly a game that deserves a chance, especially if you are a western fan or fan of shooters.
The game has a few glitches here and there (most notably in the achievements, some of which are impossible to unlock at the moment), but it is a fairly solid game over all with an interesting enough storyline to warrant at least one play through and a really fun multiplayer if you are into that.