Great game with flaws
This may very well be the best SvR game so far, at least on the current generation of consoles, but it still has more than enough flaws.
First of all, the engine has been the same since going "Next-Gen", with heavy clipping issues and all, it works fine but starts to seem outdated.
Since creating a good CAW (Create-A-Wrestler) with moves and entrance can easily take 1-2 hours, the chance to download user-created CAWs is very welcome, but the interface is clumsy, only Live Gold members are even allowed to download wrestlers, and it's impossible to edit downloaded CAWs to e.g. give them their real entrance music. A great idea executed less than great.
Other things to critisize are the sometimes dubious AI, very inconsistent difficulty level in story modes and the new HUD, although this surely is a matter of taste. A truckload of game modes, very good controls and countless create options still make this a very good wrestling game, but with some more care by the developers it could have been even better.